Reader-supported: this guide may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.
The quick answer
- Kamado: the best all-rounder. Smokes, grills and bakes pizza, and copes well with British weather. Charcoal flavour, moderate learning curve.
- Pellet grill: the easiest. Set a temperature and walk away. Milder smoke flavour, and it needs mains power.
- Offset smoker: the most hands-on and the most theatre. Best wood-smoke flavour when done well, but cheap offsets are hard to control.
- Not sure? Start on your kettle BBQ and see how much you enjoy smoking first.
Once you've caught the smoking bug, you'll quickly run into the big three: kamados, pellet grills and offset smokers. Each one suits a different kind of cook. This comparison is based on how each design works, typical UK prices and what owners report. If you're brand new to smoking, start with the best smokers for beginners.
Side-by-side comparison
| Kamado | Pellet grill | Offset smoker | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Lumpwood charcoal + wood chunks | Hardwood pellets | Wood logs or charcoal + wood |
| Ease of use | Medium | Easiest | Hardest |
| Temperature control | Vents; very stable once set | Digital controller | Constant fire management |
| Smoke flavour | Good | Mild | Strongest |
| Searing / high heat | Excellent (can exceed 350°C) | Limited on many models | Limited |
| Cold weather | Excellent (thick ceramic walls) | Uses more pellets | Thin steel struggles in wind and cold |
| Needs power? | No | Yes | No |
| Typical price | ~£300–£1,000+ | ~£400–£1,500+ | ~£150–£800+ |
Prices are rough guides and vary by model and retailer.
Kamado: the all-rounder
A kamado is a thick-walled ceramic (or insulated steel) egg-shaped cooker. The heavy walls hold heat so well that it can run at 110°C for hours on a single load of charcoal, then go up past 350°C for steaks or pizza.
- Best for: people who want one cooker for everything, and don't mind learning the vents.
- Watch out for: the weight, overshooting your target temperature (it's slow to cool down), and the price of good ceramic models.
More in are kamado grills worth it? and the best kamado grills in the UK.
Pellet grill: the easy option
A pellet grill feeds hardwood pellets from a hopper into a fire pot, with a fan and a digital controller holding the temperature you set. Many connect to an app, so you can check the cook from indoors.
- Best for: busy people who want consistent results with minimal effort.
- Watch out for: milder smoke flavour, electronics that need to stay dry, and the need for an outdoor power supply.
More in pellet grills explained.
Browse pellet grills on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Offset smoker: maximum flavour, maximum effort
An offset has a firebox on one side, with heat and smoke drawn across a long cooking chamber to a chimney. You manage a small, clean wood fire for the whole cook.
- Best for: enthusiasts who enjoy tending a fire and want the deepest wood-smoke flavour.
- Watch out for: budget models made from thin steel, which leak heat and swing in temperature, especially in a cold, windy British garden.
Char-Griller Smokin' Pro offset smoker
A classic offset smoker from Char-Griller. Around £350 at the time of writing.
A middle ground: gravity-fed charcoal
Gravity-fed charcoal smokers combine charcoal flavour with digital temperature control. Charcoal drops from a hopper into a firebox, and a fan holds the temperature you set. Like a pellet grill, they need power.
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600
A digital charcoal grill and smoker with app control. Around £799 at the time of writing.
Prices at the time of writing. Some items are sold by marketplace partners through The Range.
Which should you buy?
- You want one cooker that does everything: a kamado.
- You want easy, reliable results and have a power supply: a pellet grill.
- You love fire, have time, and want the most flavour: a well-built offset.
- You want charcoal flavour with push-button control: a gravity-fed charcoal smoker.
- You're just curious: try smoking on a charcoal kettle first.
Whichever you choose, read our smoking wood guide and try pulled pork as your first cook.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, a kamado or a pellet grill?
A kamado is more versatile and gives a stronger charcoal flavour, without needing power. A pellet grill is easier and more consistent. Choose based on how hands-on you want to be.
Are offset smokers good for beginners?
Well-built heavy steel offsets can be, if you enjoy tending a fire. Cheap thin-steel offsets are often frustrating for beginners because the temperature is hard to control.
Do pellet grills give a smoky flavour?
Yes, but it's milder than charcoal and wood. Running at lower temperatures and using a smoke tube can add more smoke.
Which smoker works best in the UK weather?
Kamados cope best with cold and wind thanks to their thick walls. Pellet grills work fine but use more pellets in cold weather. Thin offsets struggle most.
Home cook, keen DIYer and long-time website builder, writing practical outdoor cooking guides for UK gardens. More about me.